top of page
Writer's pictureRALPH COPE

Getting the Best Value for a 20-Ton Excavator on a Limited Budget


When looking for a 20-ton excavator on a limited budget, it’s crucial to weigh your options between buying a new machine and exploring the used market. Both choices have their merits, and understanding the nuances of each can help you make an informed decision. Here, we'll explore the best value-for-money options for new excavators and provide guidance on finding a reliable second-hand machine.


Option 1: Best Value for Money - New Excavators

Buying a new excavator has several advantages, including warranty coverage, the latest technology, and lower maintenance costs initially. Here are some of the best value-for-money options across major OEM brands:


1. Caterpillar 320 GC

The Caterpillar 320 GC is designed to offer the best performance at a lower cost. It is built for customers who prioritize low operating costs and high efficiency. Key features include:

  • Fuel Efficiency: The Cat 320 GC consumes less fuel compared to other models in its class, making it a cost-effective choice in the long run.

  • Maintenance: Extended maintenance intervals help reduce downtime and maintenance costs.

  • Performance: While not the most powerful in the Cat lineup, it offers a balanced performance suitable for general excavation tasks.

2. Komatsu PC200-8

Komatsu is known for producing reliable and durable machinery. The PC200-8 is a great example of their commitment to quality at an affordable price. Key features include:

  • Technology: Equipped with Komatsu's advanced technology, it ensures optimal performance and efficiency.

  • Durability: Built to withstand tough conditions, ensuring a longer lifespan.

  • Comfort: Operator comfort is enhanced with a spacious cabin and ergonomic controls.

3. Hyundai HX220L

Hyundai's HX series offers robust machines at competitive prices. The HX220L is designed for efficiency and durability. Key features include:

  • Fuel Efficiency: Advanced engine technology ensures lower fuel consumption.

  • Ease of Maintenance: Simplified maintenance procedures and long intervals between services.

  • Performance: Strong hydraulic system for smooth and efficient operation.

4. Doosan DX220LC-5

Doosan is renowned for producing heavy-duty excavators that are also cost-effective. The DX220LC-5 offers several benefits:

  • Powerful Engine: Provides high performance for various applications.

  • Fuel Efficiency: Doosan's innovative technologies help reduce fuel consumption.

  • Comfort and Safety: Features a comfortable cab and advanced safety features.

5. Volvo EC220E

Volvo excavators are known for their quality and efficiency. The EC220E offers excellent performance at a reasonable cost. Key features include:

  • Fuel Efficiency: Volvo's advanced engine technology ensures optimal fuel consumption.

  • Operator Comfort: Spacious and ergonomic cab design.

  • Durability: Built to last with high-quality components and materials.


Option 2: Finding a Reliable Second-Hand Excavator

If a new machine is beyond your budget, purchasing a used excavator can be a viable option. However, it requires careful consideration to avoid potential pitfalls. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you find a reliable second-hand excavator:


Step 1: Determine Your Requirements

Before starting your search, clearly define what you need in terms of:

  • Operating Hours: Look for machines with lower operating hours, as they generally have more life left.

  • Application: Ensure the machine meets the specific requirements of your projects.

  • Budget: Set a realistic budget considering not just the purchase price but also potential repairs and maintenance.

Step 2: Research and Identify Potential Sellers

  • Dealerships: Reputable dealerships often offer used equipment with some form of warranty or certification.

  • Online Marketplaces: Websites like Machinery Trader, Equipment Trader, and IronPlanet list used excavators from various sellers.

  • Auction Sites: Platforms like Ritchie Bros. Auctioneers and eBay Motors can have good deals, but they come with risks.

  • Networking: Industry contacts and forums can provide leads on reliable used machines.

Step 3: Conduct a Thorough Inspection

Before making a purchase, a thorough inspection is crucial. Here’s what to look for:

  • Service History: Ask for the machine’s maintenance records to ensure it has been well cared for.

  • Visual Inspection: Check for signs of wear and tear, rust, and any visible damage.

  • Undercarriage: Inspect the undercarriage for wear, as it is one of the most expensive parts to replace.

  • Hydraulic System: Look for leaks and test the hydraulic performance.

  • Engine: Listen for unusual noises and check for exhaust smoke, which could indicate engine issues.

  • Functionality Test: Operate the machine to ensure all controls and functions are working properly.

Step 4: Consider a Professional Evaluation

If you’re not confident in your ability to assess the machine, hiring a professional inspector can be a worthwhile investment. They can provide a detailed report on the condition of the excavator, helping you avoid costly mistakes.

Step 5: Evaluate the Seller

  • Reputation: Research the seller’s reputation through reviews and ratings.

  • Experience: Prefer sellers with experience in dealing with heavy machinery.

  • After-Sales Support: Check if the seller offers any after-sales support or warranty.


Major OEM Brands for Second-Hand Excavators

1. Caterpillar

Caterpillar machines are known for their durability and reliability, making them a popular choice in the used market. Key considerations:

  • Availability: Wide availability of spare parts and service centers.

  • Resale Value: Caterpillar excavators retain their value well.

  • Common Models: CAT 320D, 320C.

2. Komatsu

Komatsu is another reliable brand with a good reputation in the used market. Key considerations:

  • Durability: Known for robust construction and long lifespan.

  • Technology: Even older models come with advanced features.

  • Common Models: PC200-7, PC210-8.

3. Hyundai

Hyundai offers cost-effective machines that perform well in various conditions. Key considerations:

  • Affordability: Typically more affordable than other major brands.

  • Performance: Reliable performance with good fuel efficiency.

  • Common Models: R220LC-9S, HX220L.

4. Doosan

Doosan excavators are known for their power and efficiency. Key considerations:

  • Powerful Engines: Provide excellent performance in demanding conditions.

  • Ease of Maintenance: Simplified maintenance procedures.

  • Common Models: DX225LC, DX220LCA.

5. Volvo

Volvo machines are built for efficiency and operator comfort. Key considerations:

  • Fuel Efficiency: Known for low fuel consumption.

  • Comfort: Comfortable and ergonomic cab design.

  • Common Models: EC220D, EC220E.


Financing and Purchasing

New Excavator Financing Options

  1. Manufacturer Financing: Many OEMs offer financing options for new machines. Caterpillar, Komatsu, and Volvo have their financing arms that provide competitive rates.

  2. Bank Loans: Traditional bank loans can be a viable option, especially if you have a good credit history.

  3. Leasing: Leasing a new excavator can reduce upfront costs and provide flexibility.


Used Excavator Financing Options

  1. Dealership Financing: Some dealerships offer financing for used equipment.

  2. Equipment Loans: Specialized lenders provide loans for used machinery, often at higher interest rates than new equipment loans.

  3. Personal Loans: If other options are not viable, a personal loan might be considered, though it generally comes with higher interest rates.


Maintenance and Warranty Considerations

New Excavators

  1. Warranty: New excavators come with manufacturer warranties, covering parts and labor for a specified period.

  2. Service Plans: Many OEMs offer service plans that include regular maintenance, reducing the risk of unexpected repairs.

Used Excavators

  1. Extended Warranty: Some dealerships offer extended warranties on used machines.

  2. Maintenance Records: Ensure you have access to the machine’s maintenance history to plan future services.


Conclusion

When looking for a 20-ton excavator on a limited budget, it’s essential to weigh the pros and cons of buying new versus used. New machines like the Caterpillar 320 GC, Komatsu PC200-8, Hyundai HX220L, Doosan DX220LC-5, and Volvo EC220E offer advanced technology, efficiency, and lower initial maintenance costs. However, if a new machine is beyond your budget, buying a reliable second-hand excavator from reputable brands like Caterpillar, Komatsu, Hyundai, Doosan, or Volvo can be a practical solution. Ensure thorough inspection, evaluate the seller’s reputation, and consider professional evaluation to avoid potential pitfalls. With careful consideration and research, you can find an excavator that meets your needs and budget, ensuring your projects run smoothly and efficiently.


Comments


bottom of page